Sunday, August 2, 2015

Pain-bearer, Light-bringer

“What is to give light must endure the burning.” Viktor Frankl. In 1972, Frankl tried to counteract the prevalent stereotype about American college students – that all they wanted out of life was to make money. In a survey, he pointed out, only 16% of American college students had a main goal to make money. 78% of American students listed their main goal as finding a meaning and purpose in his or her life. I love Frankl’s work. If you aren’t familiar with him, he developed “logotherapy,” the “third Viennese School of psychotherapy,” following in the footsteps of Freud and Adler.

Frankl was Jewish and born in Austria. He turned 40 during the Holocaust, which he survived although his wife at the time did not. He taught at the University of Dallas for a while, and was so well regarded, he was made an honorary citizen of Texas! J He also taught at Cambridge and Harvard, but returned to Austria. He wrote 39 books based on his ideas about the human search for meaning, and he based much of his theory on what he witnessed and survived during the Holocaust. His thoughts echo many of the ideas from other survivors of the same imprisonment and massacre. Specifically, Elie Wiesel and Gerda Weissman Klein expressed deep commitment to the idea that meaning and attitude were everything to them and to the others who survived the concentration camps and death marches. How the survivors dealt with the atrocities were critical to how they made it through and continued thriving lives helping others in the aftermath.

Logotheraphy maintains the primary motivational force within humans is the drive to find meaning in life. Frankl proposed there are three principles supporting this theory: Life has meaning under ALL circumstances (including misery), the main motivation for life is our will to find a purpose/meaning, and we have freedom to find meaning in what we do or experiences (freedom to adjust our attitudes). Frankl equated the human “spirit” to the WILL to live, not a religious interpretation. Many will also equate spirit to the soul. I say that is up to you – your life, your spirit, your definition.

Frankl believed that humans were capable of resisting and braving the worst conditions, and his personal experiences/observations supported that belief. Two objective tests have been developed to measure a human’s meaning and purpose (PIL and SONG). They are used to predict how well a person might respond to logotherapy as a treatment.

As a storyteller, I find that it is easy for me to adhere to an interpretation that we all seek meaning in our lives. I have also seen it in action. Logotherapists argue that psychological damage occurs when something or someone blocks a person’s search for meaning. In some ways, this corresponds to Jung’s theories about the collective unconscious and understanding the anima/animus. Breaking away from the collective unconscious is one step toward a person’s individuation instead of enculturation and conformity. Finding one’s meaning in life is not easy, especially when it flies directly in the face of how we have been taught to behave and believe. Finding meaning in miserable circumstances is often a painful process. We don’t always get to choose our situations, like being born into a preacher’s household, or having a parent elected the US president. Those societal roles come with certain societal expectations – the person brought into that circumstance against their will, may or may not suffer depending upon how well that person can adapt the circumstance related to his or her meaning in life. Therefore, we humans have a multitude of sayings about surviving the fire, coming through the valley of shadow, and other comparisons to escaping a harrowing ordeal.

This symbolism was the major impetus behind my choice of a phoenix for the tattoo on my left arm. The tattoo serves me as a daily reminder that I have not only survived some miserable situations, but I have also thrived despite them. I have something to give back to others because I believe they can survive and thrive too. My purpose/meaning? To give light to others – to make the world a little bit better than it was before I came into it. Reflecting on the Frankl quote above, giving light is NOT easy or pleasant. Marianne Williamson echoes this idea nicely in her quote about our deepest fear being that we will find our Light and become powerful beyond measure (made famous in the movie, Coach Carter). Think about the items that produce light: candles, lanterns, light bulbs, our sun, fire… All of these light sources produce heat, and the medium carrying the flame or glow must be able to withstand the heat, or the light dies. The medium must ENDURE that which brings forth the light, sometimes over and over again. OF course, this quote led me to look up the definition of the word “endure.” Frankl was not a native English speaker, so I just wanted to be sure I understand the nuance of his statement…


Merriam-Webster defines “endure” as to continue to exists in the same state or condition, to experience (pain or suffering) for a long time, and to deal with or accept (something unpleasant). I have parentheses in the definitions because to endure is what we call a “transitive” verb. It must have a direct object to convey its full action as a verb. The direct object is a noun that receives the action of the verb. OK – that’s your grammar lesson for today. Quiz tomorrow!  J Endure is a perfect example of transition/transitive action. It passes action on to another object, transforming it for the subject of the sentence, the object performing the action. So, I could re-state Frankl’s quote as “A light-bringer must endure the burning of the light source.” Endurance, that most intimidating of the words we must perform. We must bear the pain we’ve endured to bring the light (knowledge) it produces to others.  Hmmmm, what do we know about light sources and their media? How long can light sources exist before they go out? I’m going to leave the thoughts there for now. Of course, I will post a story later on the blog!  You know I can’t let this go by without an illustration – a sharing of knowledge – a light-bringing to you. I bear the pain to share the knowledge. And it’s ok. I see the light in you – I share the smiles to represent the light we can pass from one to another. It only takes a spark to ignite a large fire… I believe in you.

No comments: